"So,
we know that Hezbollah's well-trained fighters are in control of most of west
Beirut. The decision taken by Walid Jumblat and Saad al-Hariri not to fight
back in Beirut, but rather hand most of their positions to the army ended any
illusion regarding the sanctity of the "resistance" – that it would
never turn its weapons inward, for now its hands are dripping with the blood of
innocent Lebanese. But it's different in the Chouf where Jumblatt's forces
bloodied Hezbollah.
"The
Chouf is calm now after fighting over the weekend in which forces belonging to Talal
Arslan, part of the Hezbollah-led opposition, jumped sides and joined alongside
Jumblatt's men. As the Progressive Socialist Party website reports: 'The free
people of the Chouf roll back an attack by the Iranian militias causing severe
casualties in lives and equipment.'
"Hence,
Jumblatt sounded more assertive last night on
LBC news
because he knows he got the upper-hand in the Chouf battles (Reuters is
reporting at least 14 Hezbollah gunmen killed. Meanwhile, the PSP website is
claiming 32 Hezbollah fighters killed and 250 wounded.). He was willing to hand
his offices over to the army to deflect some of the tension and because he
wants to avoid a civil war."
In short,
what happened in West Beirut was a given. According to a report from the
pro-Hezbollah Lebanese paper Al-Akhbar, this coup had been planned well in
advance and its mastermind was the recently assassinated Hezbollah commander
Imad Mughniyeh. The government may in fact have forced Nasrallah to show his
hand at a time of its choosing, not his. Hezbollah's walkover in Beirut came as
a surprise to no one; nor did the performance of the army, except perhaps the
Bush administration which must now reconsider the amount of money it has spent
on equipment and training for the Lebanese Armed Forces.
As for the
pro-government fighters in Beirut, contrary to most press accounts, there are
no Sunni "militias" in the capital. Rather, it is mostly defensive
armament, private citizens with small arms defending their families, homes and
property. So it is hardly any surprise that Hezbollah managed to overrun Sunni
neighborhoods easily. But that is merely one small part of Lebanon, and while
the attention of the foreign press has focused on fighting in one sector of the
capital, events throughout the rest of the country suggest that Hezbollah's
"rout" is illusory. Tony Badran, drawing on various Lebanese accounts
and his own reporting, offers this account:
"After
taking over West Beirut, Hezbollah tried to move to the Shouf, where there are
two Shiite towns, Kayfoun and Qmatiyye. Hezbollah is trying to link them up to
the Dahieh through the Karameh road, which links Dahieh to
Choueifat-Aramoun-Doha-Deir Qoubel-Aytat-Kayfoun and Qmatiye, so that it can
make encroachments, maintain access routes and not allow the Druze to surround
the two Shiite towns.
"That
was the plan, but Hezbollah got a severe beating in the Shouf. They were not
able to penetrate anything, relying instead – for the first time in the current
fighting – on artillery/mortar fire. To no avail. Yesterday alone we heard that
seven Hezbollah fighters who tried to infiltrate got killed.
"Hence,
Hezbollah burned its Druze ally, Talal Arslan. Whatever tiny following Arslan
had before this, it's safe to say it has been seriously damaged. Witness for
instance the fate of Syria's little Druze creation, the pitbull Wi'am Wahhab,
who, it is rumored, has taken his followers (which on a good day may actually
reach about 100) and left the Shouf altogether.
"Meanwhile
in Northern Lebanon, the pro-opposition Alawites are being slammed by Sunnis in
the Baal Mohsen area. Similarly, Sunnis in the Akkar area in the north attacked
and torched offices of the
SSNP, Baath party, Hezbollah
and Aoun, killing a good number of
SSNPs. As with
Arslan, we see a parallel development, former PM Omar Karami, a Sunni who is at
the same time trying to support Hezbollah while shoring up his Sunni bona
fides. So he lamented the "deep wound" that has occurred between
Sunnis and Shia, and told Hezbollah that if this becomes a sectarian fight,
then we have two choices: to either stay home, or fight with our sect.
"So
far we've had the luxury of not seeing this sad charade play out in the
Christian areas. Sleiman Frangieh has been inconspicuously quiet these last few
days. Michel Aoun, on the other hand, can't help himself. So, while there are
rumors that he might be urging Hezbollah in to East Beirut, others are watching
to see if Nasrallah will attempt to do with the tiny Shiite communities in
Nab'a, Metn, and Keserwan/Jbeil, what they did with Qmatiyye and Kayfoun.
"And
so, the Party of God has achieved the 'great victory' of conquering a few
Beiruti streets, terminating the credibility of the army, hastening the
prospect of its disintegration, and damaging beyond repair for the foreseeable future,
the Shiites' ties to the Lebanese social fabric."
Hezbollah
and its allies have won one small battle in a war that has just begun
.