There have been many discussions
about the ‘tipping point’ which led to the destruction of the Communist system
in Eastern Europe. This process was achieved by the lighting of a spark of
protest by the Russian people in the early days of June 1962; the heroes of
Bloody Sunday on the 2nd of June 1962 in Novocherkassk.
In May 1962 Khrushchev
and the Politburo decided to place Soviet nuclear missiles in Cuba to
demonstrate to the Americans what it was like to have nuclear missiles on its
borders. The leadership knew that this policy would have serious consequences
and ordered the military-industrial complex to increase armaments production.
They chose guns over butter. This dramatic shift of the national resources away
from the satisfaction of consumer demand towards expanded military capability
was a watershed in the development of the
USSR.
The country had to
tighten its belt again. The relative improvement of people's material standard
of living achieved in 1955-60 was brought to a halt. A period of unrest began.
In early 1962 in the city of
Aleksandrov
the authorities opened fire on a crowd of protesters. This marked the beginning
of a series of clashes between the people and the state, which proved that
people's trust in the authorities had been unfounded.
On
1 June a price rise for meat, butter and eggs was announced. As usual the
'necessity of important economic reforms' was advanced as an argument for this
attack on ordinary people's basic standards of living: "Everyone must
grasp that if we don't implement measures today such as an increase in the
retail price of meat, tomorrow we will see a shortage of these products and
there will be queues for meat," said Khrushchev, describing the essence of
the reforms.
Actually meat had already
disappeared from the shelves in small towns and villages. People there had to
purchase meat and other foodstuffs in the cities, or at private markets. At
markets, however, the prices depended on those in the public sector and shot up
after Khrushchev's announcement, thus making the supply situation unbearable.
The economic crisis of
1960-62 created an explosive situation. The price reform sent shock-waves
through the entire country. Indignant workers held discussions to work out what
was happening, but in the end they kept working all the same. In
Novocherkassk it was
different.
Hardest hit by the price
rise were those workers whose enterprises had just cut wages. Among them were
the workers of the 'Budyonny' Electric Locomotive Factory in
Novocherkassk. The workers got together in
groups and began discussing how they were going to make ends meet.
The situation was made worse by the
arrogant attitude of the management who ordered the workers to fall in line
with the policy. Large groups of workers formed and a strike for food was
prepared. The metalworkers’ union put up signs 'Give us meat and butter!' and
'We need flats to live in!' The slogan 'Eat minced Khrushchev!' became very
popular. The factory siren sounded brining in more workers from the nearby
workers’ suburb.
The factory management and the
police were unable to stop these workers from joining their comrades. They
refused to discuss the crisis with the workers. Soon, the discussions among the
workers turned from just food shortages to a wider discussion on the political
failings of the Soviet system. They sent out messengers to the surrounding
plants and engaged workers throughout the
Novocherkassk
factories in a united protest.
They held a mass meeting and
prepared for a march the following day, along with residents of the town and
the students, to make their protests known to the authorities.
Before breaking up their meeting, the strikers went through
the factory management's offices, collected the numerous portraits of
Khrushchev, and burnt them outside on a bonfire, leaving no doubt as to the
political nature of the movement.
That night, when the
mass-meeting was over, tanks arrived. Workers who were unable to go to sleep
that night after the heady events of the day began fighting their own Soviet
Army and 'blinded' the tanks by covering up their vision slits. In the course
of this battle a tank crashed into a pylon, knocking it over and tearing down a
power-line. The tank rolled into a trench and was unable to get out. That same
night the KGB carried out its first series of arrests, taking into custody many
of the speakers at the rally.
On the morning of 2 June
a demonstration of between 10,000 and 30,000 participants began in front of the
electric locomotive factory and set off towards the city centre. People carried
placards with slogans calling for the maintenance of social justice; there were
also portraits of Lenin. At the front were Pioneers (members of the Party
children's organization.
When the demonstrators
approached the bridge over the river Techa separating the workers' suburb from
the rest of
Novocherkassk,
they found tanks on the road ahead of them. The crowd of thousands began to
chant: "
Make Way
for the Working Class!" The tanks did not move, nor did their
crews give any sign of life, and the workers passed between them and continued
on their way.
Finally the crowd reached
the buildings of the city council and began demanding that the administrators
come out. The square was full of people, old and young. The administration had
fled through the back door. The workers’ leaders went to the balcony and spoke
on the same topic - life had become misery, and that the bureaucrats were
wallowing in luxury. Almost all those who spoke called for a continuation of
the work stoppage until the prices of meat, milk and butter were lowered and
the wages at the factory raised.
At that point in time
soldiers armed with automatic weapons were brought in. They forced back the
crowd and cleared the city council building of demonstrators. It seemed the
situation was under control and there was some possibility of negotiations. The
bulk of demonstrators then headed for police headquarters and began demanding
that those arrested be set free. But nobody was released from the cells. Then
the assembled demonstrators stormed the building.
Suddenly there were
sharp reports of machinegun fire. The soldiers opened fire on the people near
the police station. Almost immediately all the protestors at the municipal
building were fired upon by soldiers, including those high on the roofs. It was
not so much the soldiers cordoning off the city council building who fired, but
ones high up on the roofs of the buildings firing down at the mass of people
assembled in the square. Not only people in the square were killed but also in
a hairdressers' and near a shop on the far side of the square separated from the
city council building by the dense crowd.
Bullets tore through the
foliage of the trees at the very beginning of the shooting, hitting the
children there and making them drop into the crowd. Bullets bored into the
asphalt quite some distance from the scene of the massacre. All this evidence
excludes the possibility of the shooting in front of the city council being an
unfortunate coincidence - the machine-gunners stationed on the rooftops around
the perimeter of the square were clearly given the order to open fire.
Who gave the order to
open fire? It is a known fact that General Shaposhnikov refused to order the
massacre, and that cost him his career. That means the order was given higher
up. The government delegation led by A. Mikoyan and F. Kozlov arrived from
Moscow before the
massacre, so the decision cannot have been made without their knowledge.
There were bodies
everywhere, including a large number of children. However, the people were not
to be intimidated so quickly. They began coming back to the square almost
straight after the massacre, but were met by a terrible sight. The square was
awash with blood, and the trampled white sun-hats of the children stood out
against the bloody, dirty mess. The news that there had been a massacre soon
reached everyone and produced an unexpected reaction. The majority of factories
stopped work, the streets filled with people. Cars with workers drove up from
all directions. Workers got out in
Moscow
Street and walked in silence to the square in
front of the city council building in a tight, irrepressible column as wide as
the street itself. The workers filled the streets in a massive demonstration,
even though armed soldiers could be seen in the distance.
There was a sea of
people on the square in front of the city council building; almost twenty
thousand workers and their families. The tanks there tried to move off the
square, but people wouldn't let them. "Tell Khrushchev! Tell
Khrushchev!" the crowd chanted, and then: "Let him see this! Let him
see this!” Mikoyan went on radio and announced: "After consulting Nikita
Sergeyevich Khrushchev we have decided to take all measures necessary to
restore order in
Novocherkassk!"
People's reaction was most understandable:
"Come on and tell us about it, or come here and face us!" And when
nothing was forthcoming: "Ha, crawled back into his hole, has he?!"
Tanks moved up to the crowd. But the first tank stopped dead in its tracks in
front of a row of brave protesters who joined arms and blocked its path. At the
same time children climbed on top of the tank and started banging stones
against the hatch. The tanks fired blank shells which shattered nearby windows
and caused squeezing in the crowd, they also turned on their axis full circle,
but the crowd refused to disperse.
Mikoyan and his
government commission agreed to speak with the workers. He grudgingly said that
he could look into raising the wages but could do nothing about the prices. The
workers were not interested in this; they wanted to speak about the massacre of
Soviet citizens by the police and the Red Army. No progress was made. The
workers were surrounded by troops and were allowed to leave but not return.
That night the KGB struck again. During the events of the previous two days the
KGB had taken thousands of photographs so as to keep track of everything that
happened in detail. These were used to identify the 'leaders' and agitators.
Everyone who was arrested was interrogated and shown the photographs. Under
threat of punishment they were forced to reveal the identity of people they
recognized. The movement was thus deprived of its leading participants. At the
same time a curfew was imposed on the city and food supplies were improved - a
stick and carrot strategy by the authorities.
Although the revolt was hushed up and the trials not
reported the Procurator-General’s report makes it clear that the top levels of
the Soviet state were involved.”
In the morning of 2 June comrades
Kirilenko, Kozlov, Mikoyan, Il'ichev, Polyansky, Shelepin and responsible staff
of the central organs of the country arrived at the building of the City Party
Committee and City Executive Committee... F R Kozlov informed N S Khrushchev
about the situation and requested, through the Minister of Defence of the
USSR, that the
commander of troops I A Pliev be instructed to use troops to break up any
possible pogroms in the city. On 2 June internal troops were brought from
Rostov-on-Don and all were given weapons and ammunition, and by
10 o'clock all divisions of these
troops were in a state of battle-readiness
.”The authorities admitted to the deaths of 22 workers and the wounding
of 39 more. This was a gross understatement according to witnesses. About
sixteen children were murdered and many more were hurt or arrested.
The government decided to make
Novocherkassk
a ‘
Hero
City’; a designation which would allow
it to have better rations than before. The Soviet system was rocked by this
city-wide protest. The news traveled all over
Russia through the grapevine, as
well as to the neighbouring states. The working people, united, had forced
changes from the
USSR
apparat. Change was in the air and the state was shown to be vulnerable.
It was this news which inspired workers organizations across the Soviet
Empire to think they had a chance to change the system. It was an inspiration
to Solidarnosc who referred to it in its early organizational pamphlets. This
was not East German or
Poznan
rioters on the fringe; this was an explosion in the very heart of the beast.
So, when evaluating the causes of the implosion of the Soviet system, it
would be a mistake to undervalue the heroic struggles of the workers of
Novocherkassk. They were
an important first step which inspired others.